Sunday, March 14, 2010

The relative invisibility of systemic prejudice

I have included a link to part 1 of a 6 part talk given by Tim Wise on the Pathology of White Privilege. I think it is highly worthwhile to view all six parts, and they may be found on youtube. However, I have included only this first part as a good introduction to the idea of systemic racism and white privilege.

The clip discusses the many ways that privilege manifests in society, in politics and law enforcement, for example. The difficulty with privilege is that, by its inherent nature, it is invisible. Privilege is the status quo. It takes a level of cultural awareness and an appreciation for diversity to combat the power of privilege. This class has focused on building cultural awareness and awareness of our own biases and perspectives, our own ways of experiencing privilege in society. Just think, for a minute, about privilege in education, and how often we take a course that never, ever mentions issues of race and culture. Think of your latest history, science, or economics course, for example. Perhaps, if the teacher was especially culturally sensitive, there was a week where contributions from non-white races and non-western cultures were honored. Most likely, race and culture were never mentioned and whole segments of society and huge issues remained invisible. Assumptions of white privilege prevailed in textbooks, in classroom discussions, in research, and in philosophies. This is just one small example of how privilege colors our views of society, of everything. And this is true even if we are not members of the privileged class. A member of a non-privileged group experiences the same biased education, for example, as a member of the privileged group. Tim Wise talks about law enforcement and the biased beliefs of police officers despite data that contradicts those beliefs. Often, an officer of color holds the very same belief, even though it is biased against people of his/her race. The task of combatting this pervasive perspective of privilege seems overwhelming. How do we do it? What steps, no matter how small, can each individual take to combat the effects of such privilege? What is one's role as a member of the privileged culture? As a member of a non-privileged culture? These are the questions we need to ask ourselves.

13 comments:

  1. What a wonderful and powerful clip. The way Tim Wise described privilege and it's history helps me to see the roots of privilege and clarifies its continuation.
    Also your blog post is very interesting and you are right, those are questions we must ask ourselves, and I believe we are learning to do just that through this class.
    Thank you for the very valuable information!

    ReplyDelete
  2. This clip was really intense... I thought what he was saying was really important but I think I personally respond better to calm tones... call me a social worker haha... I have found myself asking questions about privilege since starting this class so I like that your blog adds to my questioning.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I am glad that your group chose privilege for your blog topic because you have really expanded on my understanding. I like the Tim Wise video and I hope to watch the other parts soon. In response to your comment that privilege is hidden, I wonder if society would view privilege as racism, sexism, ageism, and discrimination if it were more transparent?

    ReplyDelete
  4. I agree with Jarica. This clip is very powerful but I also was distracted by Tim's delivery of the speech. He was, you could tell, very angry and although he has a right to be, his anger distracted me a little from his message rather than making his case.
    Also, I think Carolyn's questions are good ones. I don't have the answer but I believe that if privilege were not hidden it would be considered as discrimination and prejudice. I think, maybe, that it is our job to look without ourselves and make it less hidden and more transparent.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I believe Tim Wise was VERY compassionate at getting the point of privilege. I found myself drawn more to the video because of the compassion and dedication he spoke with on the issue. I found this video a great way to be educated more and gain another tool as a social worker to work with in regards to privilege. So many times as you have said, this topic and the extentions of it are "wiped under the carpet" and not put out on the table. I feel if more people were like Tim Wise and had the strength to put these issues on the table, as he did, being a privileged white american, maybe more people, such as many of us taking this class, will take a better look inward and take the effort to make more change.

    ReplyDelete
  6. The clip was powerful and useful in seeing how privilege can effect all people. I have had a lot of questions concerning privilege and how it can affect my career as a social worker. If it affects police officers who are also in a filed that tries to protect all people how than can I make sure that it stays neutral or at least be able to maintain an open mind and an nonjudgmental feelings toward another person? This clip really helped.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I am glad that you chose to post about privilege because I think it is a key element to recognize and challeng our privileges both individualy and as the groups that we identify with. I often check in with myself in my line of work. I work in a domestic violence shelter. I recogize that I have a level of given power and privilege over the residents that stay at the shelter. Power just in the fact that I am paid to be at the shelter evry day and privileg that I can go home to my own home everyday at the end of each day. I have actually had residents at the shelter say to me "must be nice to be able to go home to your house where it is nice and quiet and no one is stealing your stuff or screaming in the middle of the night." This can be hard to hear but important to hear and recognize the differences in power and privileges between professional and client. If I just go along and pretend like the privileges and power dynamics are the same I am only fooling myself and not being honest with myself or others. It is important to make sure that I am aware of the inherent power and privileges so that I do not misuse these.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Heather, thank you for sharing your story with us. I commend you for the work you do. I did an internship with abused women and it was just too hard for me. I found I carried it around with me and was not able to let it go at the end of the day. I am grateful for people like you who can do the job that some others cannot.
    I also note the differences in the way we have all reacted to Tim's presentation. Some of us thought his presentation was a little well not calm, while others found it filled with compassion and was better able to relate. I like that we can express our differences in a safe place. I find that yelling doesn't help me to absorb the material, rather it distract me from the message, and perhaps reminds me of my childhood.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Also, Cindy, I think you make a good point. While I did enjoy the presentation because it was educational and thought provoking the way he deliverd it made me feel guilt and I felt like I was being yelled at. Not until I read your post did I realize I felt like a child being repremanded. But all in all I love lectures so I enjoyed this one as well.

    ReplyDelete
  10. That was a really great clip, I'm going to find the time to watch the rest of the series. Heather I agree with you, We must recognize and challenge our privilages as a group and indaviduals and I think that this class,is opening up door for us to examine alot of aspects of our lives that we may not have given any thought to before. It has been a huge learnig experiance for me to see everyones blogs and see their interests. Thanks!

    ReplyDelete
  11. I really enjoyed the clip and the whole segment. It is bringing in the open an issue that no one seems to know anything about. I think it is our duty to our society to spread the knowledge on this topic with our friends and family in the very least to spread some knowledge. Great topic and well said!

    ReplyDelete
  12. i think its interesting that you mentioned privilege and the biased beliefs of police officers in your post this week....this makes me think of racial profiling which I think is a huge issue in this country...especially since 9'11. While I agree that law enforcement should be aware of people who are involved in suspicious activity...who determines which people merely LOOK suspicious enough to profile?? really? my brother is half mexican and he has been pulled over many times for looking like someone described from a report. One night an officer came to our house at 2 a.m. after following my brother home the night before to talk to him because he saw him an thought he looked like a man described in a criminal act the night before. My brother was nowhere near where that man was that night.

    ReplyDelete
  13. This was very informative. I love having something to watch! Tim Wise was very insightful but seemed a bit like he was punishing me and yelling at me. Privilege is something that i never really considered before this class to be honest. I am very glad you chose this for the blog!

    ReplyDelete